Shame A Critical Point Of A Person s Moral Development...

Shame is philosophically understood to be a critical point in a person s moral development. A mature moral agent has their own standards and self evaluates on shame based on relevant criticisms. Cheshire Calhoun argues the position that one feel shame while still being a morally developed agent. This is in contrast to some of additional theories in the field such as the ‘Moral Pioneer’ and ‘Socially Discriminating Actor’, which hold that shame stems from to the individual s appraisal of externals criticisms. These differences arise from trying to understand if a mature moral agent could feel shame in relation to another s criticisms which they do not agree with, but agree with on some framework level. I personally agree with much of Cheshire Calhoun s conclusions on the matter which demonstrate an understanding of the social practicality of group values and communal expectations. This allows shame to be experienced in a situation where another colleague coul d bring in social factors which would influence a shame response due to subordinate identities that should be factored for in the situation. The differences I have with Calhoun arise when we factor for the internet and the roles of social interaction that are simultaneously real and artificial which demands a redefining of terms. I agree that shame cannot be understood outside its social circumstances without delimiting its importance. In order to properly argue for my position I must give definition of terms andShow MoreRelatedAdolescence Is A Critical Time For A Human1405 Words   |  6 Pages Identity development is a fluid process throughout the human life cycle. Seemingly, adolescence, development after the age of 12 through young adulthood, is the most difficult transitive period in the life cycle. Adolescence is a critical time for a human, because it is the period when various personal roles are examined and one tries to assimilate these roles into a perception of sel f. Adolescents are struggling to identify different areas in their life such as religious preferences, sexualityRead MoreThe Origins Of Virtue By The Zoologist Matt Ridley1509 Words   |  7 Pagesand embryo relationship. Next, the division of labour is examined using the notion of Adam Smith about specialization which is essential to trade and elevates the society to be more than just the sum of its parts. Chapter 3 is devoted to the Prisoner s Dilemma from game theory, which can be traced through the rest of the book. It deals with how people are led by self-interest or cooperation, how reciprocal humans and animals are because eventually we gain more from cooperation, despite the temptationRead MoreFranz Boas : Cultural Anthropology Essay817 Words   |  4 Pagesvalues, beliefs, history, and the previous thought of parallel evolutionism was in fact extremely untrue. Boas believed that cultural development was not autonomous and could be reached via multiple different routes in cluding trade, corresponding environment, and historical accident. In addition to Boas’s distrust in pretentious generalizations he was profusely critical of racism and any sciences inspired by it. During this time period, many anthropologists believed that racial inferiority explainedRead MoreConscience Is A Critical Inner Awareness1451 Words   |  6 Pagesdescribes an aspect of a human being s self-awareness. It is part of a person s internal rational capacity and is not, as popular lore sometimes suggests, an audience room for the voice of God or of the devil. Conscience is a critical inner awareness that bears witness to the norms and values we recognize and apply. The complex of values with which conscience deals includes not only those we own, but the entire range of values to which we are exposed during life s journey. Consequently, there is alwaysRead MoreThe And Moral Tragedy Of The Don Ts And Be Carefuls Essay1419 Words   |  6 Pagestaking off in the early 190 0’s, a prominent and harmful set of guidelines was introduced by the Motion Picture Production Code. These industry censorship rules, entitled the â€Å"The Don ts and Be Carefuls, included restrictions ranging from not allowing a woman and man to be in a bed together, to forbidding the deliberate seduction of girls (Haynes, 2000). Unsurprisingly, the topic of abortion was severely stigmatized, and only to be depicted as a â€Å"personal and moral tragedy†. By 1956, the guidelineRead MoreMoral Psychology : A Long Standing Rationalist Tradition3611 Words   |  15 PagesAbstract Moral psychology has a long-standing rationalist tradition focused on reasoning. More recent evidence emphasizes the role of emotions in models of moral development and behavior (Gilligan, 1993; Haidt, 2001). Yet, both reason and emotion likely play an important role in moral judgment. â€Å"Moral emotions† have been the focus of several recent empirical psychological studies. They differ from basic emotions in that they are intrinsically linked to the interests or welfare either of societyRead MoreLifespan Psychology4621 Words   |  19 PagesLifespan Psychology Developmental Theory Key Proponent Stages/ Phases Psychosexual Freud Oral Stage : This occurs from birth to about 1 year. During this stage, the infant s primary source of interaction occurs through the mouth, so the rooting and sucking reflex is especially important. The mouth is vital for eating, and the infant derives pleasure from oral stimulation through gratifying activities such as tasting and sucking. As a result of the infant being entirely dependent upon caretakersRead MoreEugenics : Past Shames, Future Hopes2185 Words   |  9 PagesAntelope Valley College â€Æ' Eugenics: Past Shames, Future Hopes MY PICK After perusing the suggested articles, I decided on this article for my journal review because of the many facets of its colorful history in addition to its fascinating, and vastly growing, advancements in the area of eugenics. The imminent debates resulting from the conflicting moral and ethical implications arising from the inception, development and evolution of eugenics past and present are of interest.Read MoreSexual Minority Youth And Juvenile Justice System1920 Words   |  8 Pages/ Problem: Sexual Minority youth (SMY) involved with the Juvenile Justice System (JJS) have a culture that require sensitivity treatment . Many youth that identify as or question their sexuality have experience prejudice attitudes from the initial point of entry( arrest). Navigating through the JJS has been a harsh and unwarranted experience with many fearing their safety from other inmates and staff. Many staff lack the knowledge of the societal realities that SMY struggle with. In addition, di fferentialRead MoreOedipus Data Sheet2569 Words   |  11 Pagescame back from the Oracle of Delphi and told the most significant aspect of the story: the fact that the murder of Laius was the only thing that would raise the plague from the city. Oedipus vows to find and punish the perpetrator, which was his critical mistake, because in an ironic twist, it would end up being him. However, a heated debate ensues, where the king argues with some uncooperative individuals, so the king then calls upon the blind oracle/prophet Tiresias to settle the issue. Tiresias